Skip to Content

11+ Best Anna Maria Island Florida Restaurants (Local Approved)

11+ Best Anna Maria Island Florida Restaurants (Local Approved)

For those staying in Florida, you are often going to hear about Anna Maria Island.

We have been to Christmas in Florida and good RV parks in Florida, but there is a sense of charm that Anna Maria Island brings that’s hard to find elsewhere.

We are foodies, so we are always on the hunt for good food.

This is why we wanted to find good restaurants on Anna Maria Island in Florida. Since we took the time to head out here, we knew the food was going to be decent.

We have compiled a list of the best Anna Maria Island restaurants and why they are so good.

Top Anna Maria Island Restaurants

The Waterfront Restaurant

The Waterfront Restaurant is a world-class establishment with a beautiful view.

We loved our time here because their menu was well-rounded and the customer service was great. We tried the seafood at the location and it was exceptional. They prepare the meal with care and the vibe inside the restaurant is great too.

It’s one of the best restaurants in Anna Maria Island right now.

The Porch

The Porch is renowned for its burgers and that’s what we would recommend getting here.

You are going to be visiting a sleek, modern restaurant in Anna Maria Island that has gained the trust of the locals and visitors coming to the island. We had a lovely time here because their menu was wonderful and the service was excellent.

We loved the vibe inside the restaurant and their prices were decent too.

Sandbar Restaurant

Imagine you are coming to Anne Maria Island on a warm day and just want to relax under the sun.

We have been in this position before and that’s why we decided to go to the gorgeous Sandbar Restaurant. This is one of the premier restaurants on the island and it has a beautiful view of the water from where you are located.

We took the time to get a meal from this restaurant and then relax by the water. It simply does not get better than this!

Pizza Social

For those who are in the mood for pizza, it’s essential to look for a highly-rated pizza shop on Anna Maria Island such as Pizza Social.

We adore Pizza Social and feel they offer great pizza.

The toppings are wonderful and the way they bake the pizza is incredible. You can tell they have got this down to a science and the consistency of their pizza is hard to beat!

We enjoyed being able to settle in and just soak in the aroma. It was fascinating and the taste was wonderful too.

Skinny’s Place

This is a unique name and it’s going to make you wonder about the portions you’re going to get when you are in the restaurant!

However, you are not going to be disappointed.

Skinny’s Place is the real deal and the burgers are some of the best you are going to get at the Manatee Public Beach. You are not going to feel too skinny after you eat one of these burgers!

Star Fish Company

Seafood is one of those foods you are going to want to eat when you’re on Anna Maria Island. The vibe of the region along with the restaurants will make you crave this type of meal.

When we wanted to eat seafood, we took the time to go to Star Fish Company in Cortez.

It was a great decision because the simplicity of the seafood was wonderful. They keep things simple and make sure the focus is on the taste. You are going to take the food and go making it perfect for those who are walking around or just looking for an affordable meal.

Ugly Grouper

Ugly Group has become one of the more popular restaurants on the island.

We had a lovely time going to Ugly Grouper because they offer a long list of delightful grouper dishes. You are going to enjoy being able to choose one of these dishes and get them at good prices.

The meals are great and the service is quick. You are not going to be disappointed when you come here.

Tide Tables

When listing the top restaurants on Anna Maria Island, it makes sense to talk about the wonderful Tide Tables.

Tide Tables is close to Bradenton Beach and is highly rated for being one of the best restaurants in the region due to its view. The view is incredible because you are going to see the rustling of the water once you are there and the menu is great too.

We feel this is one of those locations where you get the best of everything. The ambiance is right and so is the food.

Wicked Cantina

Wicked Cantina has been established as one of the livelier restaurants on the island.

When you walk in, you are going to be greeted by a friendly staff and a team that has worked hard on perfecting its meals. This includes the incredible tacos and we loved every bite that we took.

They have seasoned the tacos perfectly and you can tell they care. It’s also a clean establishment, which makes it far more appealing for picky tourists.

The Rod and Reel Pier

Imagine being able to settle close to the pier and just exploring a restaurant that has some of the best views on the island.

The Rod and Reel Pier is all about the experience as you are going to be settled experiencing a beautiful view of the water while getting high-grade seafood at the same time. It’s set over the water, which makes it a unique experience.

If you want something different, you are going to want to head to this restaurant. It’s the complete package.

Anna Maria Oyster Bar

Anna Maria Oyster Bar has been rated as a classic Anna Maria Island restaurant.

This is a restaurant that has been around for a while and is now established as a premier destination for foodies. We loved the breakfast items that were available here because we went earlier in the day but their entire menu is great.

We recommend taking in the sights around the location while also getting your hands on good food.

Located on the Historic Bridge Street Pier, Anna Maria Oyster Bar is another local institution. For no other reason than basking in this glorious setting while your friends back home are shivering in the winter, go to Anna Maria Oyster Bar. While I ordered an omelet, my friends all opted for the Hangover Sandwich.

Final Thoughts

These are the best restaurants on Anna Maria Island in Florida.

You can’t go wrong with any of these restaurants when it’s time to eat a hearty meal.

We also want you to read about the top day trips from Tampa, going to Pine Island in Florida, and the top old towns in Florida.